Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Jul 2, 2021. It is now read-only.

Add ability to flag an image for various issues or suggest an edit #133

Open
BrightRaven opened this issue Jun 20, 2018 · 1 comment
Open
Labels
needs investigation We need to confirm what's going on

Comments

@BrightRaven
Copy link

Issues may include:

  • inappropriate content (foul language mostly - this will be more useful when public can submit images and tags)
  • typos in title, description, or tags
  • incorrect pin label (year, affiliate, name of set, etc.)
  • set is incomplete (for photos of full sets) or photo contains a pin that doesn't belong in the set
  • image is poor quality (bad lighting, bad cropping, blurry, low resolution, etc.)
  • request to combine: image is a duplicate of another pin already listed on the database (have to be careful with this one as some pins are very subtly different but appear identical at first glance)

Edits may include:

  • suggest a new tag
  • suggest a new image to add (especially for things like pins that open/move/blink)
  • add a pin designer
  • add more information about the theme of the pin or the story behind its creation

For now, these types of flags would alert a moderator to address the issue manually. In the future we may be able to automate some of these changes and just have a moderator check off on it.

@BrightRaven
Copy link
Author

This was going to be a separate ticket, but I'll just add on to this. #180 #181

We have the ability to edit text on an uploaded pin but we don't have a way to identify what needs fixing. I suggest implementing a system of flags so users and moderators can indicate to others that an edit needs to be made.

We need a new interface in the editing section. It would probably be easiest to have a series of questions or drop-down menus to guide the person to the correct flag assignment. (Like Sirena suggested for pin upload flow for general users.)

For example the flow might look like this:
"Is the issue with the image?" [Yes/No]
If yes, apply Poor Quality Image Flag
If no, ask: "Is something incorrect or missing? [Incorrect/Missing/ItsSomethingElse]
If Incorrect, provide a drop-down with "Please select the problem" and "Go Back"
If Missing, provide a drop-down with "Please select the problem" and "Go Back"
If ItsSomethingElse, provide a drop-down with "Please select the problem" and "Go Back"
etc.

Some of this may be duplicated above:
Unidentified Information:

  • Unidentified year
  • Unidentified Affiliate/Region
  • Unidentified Set Association (we don't know what set it belongs to, if any)
  • Unidentified Artist (not sure if this one should be added right now, but maybe in the future)
  • Unidentified Subject Matter (i.e. we have no clue what the pin is supposed to be)

Something is Incorrect:

  • Incorrect Title
  • Incorrect Affiliate/Region
  • Incorrect Set Association
  • Incorrect Artist
  • Incorrect Subject Matter
  • Incorrect Tag
  • Incorrect Year

Miscellaneous:

  • Poor Quality Image
  • Needs ID (is this actually a DI pin or not)
  • Missing Pin (A set is incomplete)
  • Mistake Pin (There are a rare number of these because of a manufacturing defect. This pin is not representative of the majority.)

@scytherswings scytherswings added the needs investigation We need to confirm what's going on label Jun 2, 2019
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Labels
needs investigation We need to confirm what's going on
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants