[BUG] inconsistent icon size

[mageOfstructs]

Checklist before submitting an issue

• I have searched through the existing closed and open issues for eww and made sure this is not a duplicate
• I have specifically verified that this bug is not a common user error
• I am providing as much relevant information as I am able to in this bug report (Minimal config to reproduce the issue for example, if applicable)

Description of the bug

icons aren't equally sized, even when apps provide a .svg

Reproducing the issue

(defwindow bar
  :monitor 0 ;; Optional for X11
  :stacking "fg"
  :exclusive true
  :geometry (geometry
              ;; :width "1550px"
	      :width "98%"
              :height "3%"
	            :y "1%"
	            :anchor "top center")
  (box
    (for iconName in {["org.xfce.thunar", "librewolf"]}
      (image :icon {iconName}
             :icon-size "large-toolbar"
      )
    )
  )
)

Expected behaviour

Icons should be the same size

Additional context

No response

Platform and environment

OS: archlinux
WM: hyprland 0.46.0 (wayland)
eww 0.6.0 6ee1667

[andi242]

thanks for the hint! I was looking for a way to display icons from themes :)

I can confirm the behaviour, though. image-width/image-height seem to have no effect either.
I was able to get a consistent icon size with switching icon themes (eww inspector > visual > icon theme).
PlasmaXDark was different sizes while kora was consistent.

so perhaps it's not something eww related?

applying scss did not do anything to the icons.

[mageOfstructs]

Huh, my icon theme isn't even recognized by the inspector. Switching it to anything else fixes the issue mostly, however thunar still doesn't play along. This seems more and more like a gtk issue.

[andi242]

I tried to apply icon sizes via ~/.config/gtk-3.0/settings.ini (and in gtk-4.0), which would not work either.

gtk docs say to do:

[Settings]
gtk-icon-sizes=gtk-large-toolbar=12,12:gtk-dialog=48,48

which should change icon sizes on large-toolbar
...no change in sizes, no matter what.

/edit

uh... changing :icon-size from large-toolbar to dialog in the for statement, did equal sizes on every icon. 👀

[mageOfstructs]

It must be somewhat dependent on the icon theme too. changing icon-size to dialog does make it better, except for the cinny logo (see image).

Cinny also only provides three icons from what I can tell: one 32x32, one 128x128 and one 256x256. Maybe it can't scale them down? Could explain why larger icon-sizes seem to not have this issue as much as the smaller ones.